menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
STAR TREK BBS
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Comics Review : Star Trek Movie Adaptation  Issue 5

Features

By GustavoLeao / 11:11, 29 July 2010 / Trek Books

Star Trek: Movie Adaptation #5  

Reviewed by Patrick Hayes aka PatBorg
  

The covers:
Two covers.  The Regular is by David Messina & Giovanna Niro.  Spock has lost his cool and is showing Kirk the error of his ways, while behind them a computer viewscreen shows some of the tips of Nero's ship.  Nicely done, capturing the emotional highlight of this issue.  The Retailer Incentive Photo Cover is a nice Ingmar Bergman-like shot of Spock and Sarek.  It, too, is an appropriate choice the foreshadows the same scene.  I've not seen this photo before, so I say "More of these!"  Overall grades for both: A  

The story:
This issue covers the 2009 film from Uhura and Spock's shocking -- and welcome -- revelation in the lift to Spock and Kirk's plan to assault Nero's ship.  The credits read as "Based on the screenplay by Roberto Orci & Alex Kurtzman.  Adaptation by Mike Johnson & Tim Jones."  In previous issues I felt that there was too much story being crammed into 22 pages.  This is not the case with this issue.  Much is covered, but I didn't feel that the art was drowned by the dialogue/story.  The issue has a good pace, and two sequences from the movie have been, thankfully, shortened (Pages 7 & 8 and 16).  There are three "new" visuals, not in the film, but from previous IDW comics, all of which occur on Page 10 (and they made me goose pimply!).  I was glad to see one of my favorite lines make it into this adaptation: the final dialogue on Page 16.  This is as smooth as it gets in an adaptation.  Overall grade: A+ (it gets the plus for those three images)  

The art:
David Messina and Claudia Balboni really click well in this comic.  Messina is a fantastic artists, in pencils and in layout, and Balboni softens his "hard" angled characters wonderfully.  If you don't like the look of Page 1 proceed no further, but why wouldn't you?  Every character resembles the actor portraying them.  And the backgrounds!  They have the potential to take readers out of a book if rendered poorly -- especially in science fiction.  Not here.  The Enterprise interiors are spot on, and the cave (for heaven's sake, I'm focusing on a cave!) is great!  Back to characters: If page 21 isn't pulling your heart out, then I congratulate you on your achieving Kolinahr.  Messina's penultimate Trek.  I'm tearing up already!  Overall grade: A+  

The inks:
Gaetano Carlucci does as great a job as Messina and Balboni.  Still, do I thank Carlucci or Balboni for the look?  Doesn't matter -- I'd buy you all a drink to thank you!  Overall grade: A+  

The colors:
Excuse my repetition in adjectives: gorgeous!  Ilaria Traversi not only gets a diverse selection of locales to color, she creates the J.J. Abrams "backlit glow" in certain panels: Panels 2, 4, and 5 on Page 1, for example.  I got tired of this in the new film and am, continually throughout this series, happy to see this directorial choice not being abused.  It was not really noticeable until Page 5, panel two, simply because it's hitting Spock's head.  I much preferred the technique in the bottom two panels.  I loved the green halls of Outpost Hunter and the red flashback.  Again, gorgeous.  Overall grade: A  

The letters:
Dialogue, narration, monster growls, firesticks, footsteps, transporters, computers, punches, and yells must have kept Neil Uyetake busy.  Overall grade: A  

The final line:
This issue was an overall better adaptation than the previous issue.  Everyone involved should be thanked for this contribution to the Star Trek universe.  Overall grade A+



More Top StoriesComments
Feb 09Zachary Quinto Says Star Trek XII is Bigger and Bolder, Says the Actors were Brought to the Process of Working the Script
3
Feb 09Chris Pine on the Casting of Rising Star Benedict Cumberbatch as the Chief Villain in Star Trek XII 0
Feb 09Evangelion Director Anno to Design Yamato 2199 Anime Opening0
Feb 08In Search of, 70s TV Series Hosted by Leonard Nimoy, Coming to DVD4
Feb 08Read a 7-Page Preview of Star Trek Legion of Super Heroes 5
2
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

Post New | Help
View:
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
This website is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc. or the "Star Trek" franchise.
The STAR TREK trademarks and logos are owned by CBS Studios Inc.
© 1996-2011 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.