menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
STAR TREK BBS
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Comics Review : Star Trek Burden of Knowledge Issue 2  

Features

By GustavoLeao / 17:39, 28 July 2010 / Trek Books

Star Trek: Burden of Knowledge #2  

Reviewed by Patrick Hayes aka PatBorg
  

The covers:
"Standard Cover" by Joe Corroney.  A flat-out fabulous fiery front featuring first officer Spock and female extraordinaire Uhura (take that, Stan Lee!).  If it's by Corroney you know it's good, and this certainly is.  The "Incentive Cover" is the "pure" artwork version of the "Standard Cover."  Both are exceptional.  Overall grade: A+  

The story:
A big thanks to whoever lobbied for the previous issue's summary on the inside front cover.  With three Trek books in one week (I'm frazzled!), this was a welcome reminder.  "A Failure to Communicate" is by Scott & David Tipton who've shown they can Trek with the best of any writer(s).  This time the brothers have the crew of the Enterprise involved with a first contact, the Waasertlans.  The smiling speaker for its denizens is A'net, who has an obvious implant on the right side of her head.  As she stutters through a greeting and concludes with an invitation to visit the surface, you know "things have...gotten a little more interesting."  Faster than you can say "Landru" the big three and Uhura (YAH!) beam down to speak with the locals.  There's no secret as to what's going on (Page 5, panels five and six), but the story's thrust begins on Page 12.  On Page 14 (panel three) you'll get every reason why not to be on Facebook or Twitter.  It's a nice analogy for modern day society.  Especially telling is the second dialogue balloon in panel four.  The solution to the story's problem is not surprising, but the results are what're interesting.  Kirk's comment on Page 20 is pure Trek.  Kirk becomes the diplomat, again, on Page 21 and it's great!  The final page reads like an episode: thoughtful commentary, Spock and McCoy banter, and the order to move on.  There's no "action" in this issue -- no fists thrown or phasers fired.  It's a conversation issue and it pushed all the right buttons for me.  Just as long as that button doesn't go "KLEK".  Overall grade: A  

The art:
I had some problems with Federica Manfredi's likenesses last issue, but that's no longer a concern.  This is a consistently drawn comic that seems that Manfredi is comfortable with: I think we're now getting "her" style.  I loved the emotions shown on many characters' faces: Kirk (Page 3, panel two), Spock (Page 22, panel five), Uhura (Page 7, panel three), and the winner of the creepiest smile since the Joker, A'net.  I also loved all the faces of the crowd on Page 16, panel three.  And those blood veins around each person's implant -- shiver!  Take that, David Messina!  Manfredi also creates some great backgrounds: the fields, the major city, the underground, and the lab.  There's a lot of detail going on.  The page layout is also good.  I'm officially a fan of Ms. Manfredi now.  Please continue to do comic books!  Overall grade: A  

The colors:
Andrea Priorini continues the Trek of excellence, from the cool interiors of the Enterprise, the red fields, the colorful city and its people, to the electricity of the lab.  Every page is a winner.  Overall grade: A  

The letters:
Chris Mowry moves in this issue and has dialogue, a transporter's whine, a crash, and a very important "KLEK".  All done well.  I really wanted some notation of music on Page 8, panel five because with the pause in Kirk's dialogue I thought he was being polite to acknowledge something he actually didn't hear (because he didn't have the implant).  It wasn't until the top of 9 that I realized that he had heard the music.  An odd absence, that was your choice, the Tiptons, or editor Scott Dunibier's.  Still, one panel against an entire issue does not slight the entire work.  Overall grade: A  

The final line:
Another enjoyable self-contained outing for the original crew.  If you'd like to re-experience the warm fuzzies that the original series gave you, this is where you should venture.  Overall grade: A   



More Top StoriesComments
Feb 09Zachary Quinto Says Star Trek XII is Bigger and Bolder, Says the Actors were Brought to the Process of Working the Script
3
Feb 09Chris Pine on the Casting of Rising Star Benedict Cumberbatch as the Chief Villain in Star Trek XII 0
Feb 09Evangelion Director Anno to Design Yamato 2199 Anime Opening0
Feb 08In Search of, 70s TV Series Hosted by Leonard Nimoy, Coming to DVD4
Feb 08Read a 7-Page Preview of Star Trek Legion of Super Heroes 5
2
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

Post New | Help
View:
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
This website is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc. or the "Star Trek" franchise.
The STAR TREK trademarks and logos are owned by CBS Studios Inc.
© 1996-2011 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.