menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
STAR TREK BBS
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Comics Review : Star Trek Leonard McCoy Frontier Doctor Issue 4

Features

By GustavoLeao / 17:01, 28 July 2010 / Trek Books

Star Trek: Leonard McCoy, Frontier Doctor #4  

Reviewed by Patrick Hayes aka PatBorg
  

The covers:
Cover A has the good doctor teaching anatomy to a class.  There are several familiar species and some new ones in attendance.  John Byrne provides the art while Lovern Kindzierski provides the great colors.  The same pair do Cover B, the continuing of good bad doctor jokes.  These have been my favorite covers of the series, and this cover also made me chuckle.  Cover R(etailer) I(ncentive) is the same as B without Kindzierski's contributions.  You couldn't go wrong with any of these choices.  Overall grades: All three A+  

The story:
A nice unexpected surprise: Two eleven page stories within, not the typical twenty-two page yarn.  Normally I don't like to go into details about an issue past Page 4, but since these are shorter stories I'm not going to go beyond the first two pages for specifics, then I'm going to be vague.  "Hosts" begins with McCoy saying good-bye to his co-stars from last issue.  It's a nice farewell to Duncan and Theela, and with the established time of their one year adventures I can only hope to see their return with some "lost" adventures.  Gary and Roberta go too, and Roberta drops a nice teaser as to their future destination.  The story really begins at the bottom of Page 3 and establishes who was speaking to Leonard in last issue's final panel.  "Something" has happened to a few members of the Yorktown's crew and it's up to the doctor and his "friend" to find out how and why.  Page 8 and 9 was downright creepy for me since the situation seemed so out of control.  The ultimate solution to this mystery was plausible, scientific, and fun!  The first panel of dialogue on Page 11 screams Star Trek!  And the final dialogue harkens back to some of McCoy's better closers from the episodes.  "Scalpel" is the second tale, and as much as I've enjoyed the previous tales/issues in this series, these eleven pages will probably be the most discussed.  The Doc goes to visit an old friend and his daughter on a most peaceful and successful world.  Paradise is revealed on Page 15, explained on Pages 16-19, and confronted at the bottom of 19.  It's an old fashioned morality tale.  The last half of Page 21 is terrifying and sad.  Page 22 bookends the series as it began.  Though it's joyous to see this pair, that final bit of dialogue made me wonder...And shouldn't the best stories, regardless of their genre, have you thinking about them once they're done?  Overall grade: A+  

The art:
Byrne gives so much for fans to fawn over.  All of Page 1, the many familiar faces from Trek, the strange new worlds (Pages 5, 6, 12, and 13), new life ("Hosts" and the inhabitants of Palvarlion IV), and new civilizations (Palvarlion IV, and then some).  He also continues to be the perfect teacher of page layout -- every page's final panel is a teaser or lead-in to the next.  The beauty of Page 1 and the understated horror of Page 18, panel five (how many other artists would have chosen to show the entire image?) show that Byrne can do anything.  Page 21 has nothing futuristic about it: It could be in the 19th or 21st century, but those last three panels, coupled with the story, are Star Trek perfection -- The painful/powerful choices individuals make, which is what Star Trek and John Byrne illustrate the best.  Overall grade: A+  

The colors:
Lovern Kindzierski enhances every page of this book.  My favorite examples are found in "Scalpel".  Bright colors for the current civilization and dark dirt tones for its uncivilized past.  Overall grade: A+  

The letters:
 A hail, laughter, and lots of dialogue and narration are Neil Uyetake's milieu, and he continues to do well.  Overall grade: A+  

The final line:
John Byrne consistently produces great Trek tales.  These, and this issue, should be in your collection if you're a Trek fan.  Not a fan?  Start here.  You'll get the idea.  Don't be gone too long, Mr. Byrne.  You'll always be welcome to Star TrekOverall grade: A+ 



More Top StoriesComments
Feb 09Zachary Quinto Says Star Trek XII is Bigger and Bolder, Says the Actors were Brought to the Process of Working the Script
3
Feb 09Chris Pine on the Casting of Rising Star Benedict Cumberbatch as the Chief Villain in Star Trek XII 0
Feb 09Evangelion Director Anno to Design Yamato 2199 Anime Opening0
Feb 08In Search of, 70s TV Series Hosted by Leonard Nimoy, Coming to DVD4
Feb 08Read a 7-Page Preview of Star Trek Legion of Super Heroes 5
2
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

2 comments Post New | Help
View:

Well done | Report this post to moderator
By: ZOD (Odo's file, contact) @ 08:58:10 on Jul 29, 2010

Most Trek comics have artwork that is pretty uneven. All those portraits and familiar settings clearly wear the artists down. Byrne's comics seen to get stronger as they go. His characterizations are unbelievably consistent (and believable). Maybe it's his passion for TOS, but I haven't seen him produce such consistently excellent work in many years.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
Well done indeed by GustavoLeao @ 18:49:27 on Jul 30
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
This website is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc. or the "Star Trek" franchise.
The STAR TREK trademarks and logos are owned by CBS Studios Inc.
© 1996-2011 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.