menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Comics Review : Star Trek Movie Adaptation Issue 2

Features

By GustavoLeao / 03:31, 18 March 2010 / Star Trek: Nemesis

Star Trek Movie Adaptation #2  

Reviewed by Patrick Hayes aka PatBorg
  

The covers:
As with last issue, a tight close-up on the Regular cover of a dominant character from the issue, young Spock this time.  The great team of David Messina & Giovanna Niro continue to deliver the goods as Spock's test questions are reflected in his face to perfection.  The Retailer Incentive Photo cover is that famous trailer shot of Kirk on his bike looking at the construction of the Enterprise in the Riverside Shipyard.  It, too, is a good cover but could they not give away the last page of the comic?  Yeah, we've all seen the movie and know what's coming but I would've rather had a cockeyed cover with Spock rejecting entrance into the Vulcan Science Academy.  It's a nitpick, but--HEY!--No spoilers!  Overall grade: Both covers A  

The story:
Spock's education (with teasing), Kirk crashing the car, Spock gives his sweetest "Live long and prosper", Kirk meets Uhura, Cupcake, many fists, and Pike.  That's a summary "Based on the Screenplay by Roberto Orci & Alex Kurtzman.  Adaptation by Mike Johnson & Tim Jones."  What's new?  A nice exchange between Sarek and Amanda, with a great exit line by her!  A good exchange between young Jimmy Kirk and his brother, including justification for the stealing/wrecking of his dad's car.  These two pages also justify young Jim's path until he meets up with Pike.  It's a solid story, following the film, with a few extras.  Overall grade: A  

The art:
  It's so damn good!  David Messina continues to impress.  There are panels that look straight out of the movie, but there are also several of Messina's own composition (Pages 5 & 6 and 14 & 15 come to mind).  Messina can really layout a page.  For example, sometimes in a fight scene it's difficult to tell where characters are in relation to their settings (any Frank Miller Marvel comic has the characters battling well, but against a white background).  Not Messina.  Look at Page 16, with its detailed backgrounds and layout, I know exactly where everyone is.  It's so nice to see this, and it's so appreciated.  Also always appreciated are the striking likenesses to the actors: Pine, Quinto, and Saldana are sterling.  However, Bruce Greenwood doesn't look at all like himself until a heart stopping close-up on Page 20.  Nit, nit, nit.  It's still a winning issue.  Overall grade: A  

The inks:
Gaetano Carlucci is a good match with Messina.  It finally dawned on me what her work reminds me of: Kevin Maguire's work on Justice League of America.  Yet, she doesn't make this book not look like Messina.  Could she be the new Terry Austin?  A jaw-dropping inker whose work always brought out the best in anything he inked?  I'd love to see more to compare!  Overall grade: A+  

The colors:
The flawless record of Giovanna Niro continues.  I'd move to Iowa if the sky was that bright.  I'm almost nervous about how white and bright she'll make the light (excuse the unintentional rhyme) on the bridge of the Enterprise.  Will it be as overdone as J.J. did?  Sorry, it annoyed me.  I'm anxious to see!  Overall grade: A  

The letters:
Neil "go-to" Uyetake takes over the lettering chores this issue.  Dialogue aplenty, coupled with computer speak, punches, sirens, car acceleration, crashes, broken glass, and Trek's loudest whistle.  Overall grade: A  

The final line:
Short and sweet: A worthy addition to any Trek collection.  Overall grade: A




More Top StoriesComments
Feb 12Details on Upcoming Next Generation Novel Trilogy, Cold Equations0
Feb 12First Look at the Cover of Ships of the Line 2013 Calendar0
Feb 12Star Trek Fan Day at St. Louis Science Center 0
Feb 11Doctor Who Star Trek Comic Book Crossover Coming from IDW
10
Feb 11Namco Bandai Announces Star Trek Game Spin-Off Dated for Q1 2013
0
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

4 comments Post New | Help
View:

Waiting For The TPB | Report this post to moderator
By: Jean-Luc (Odo's file, contact) @ 04:05:50 on Mar 18, 2010 | Edit History (2)

Sorry, I'm too cheap to spend $4 or $5 an issue with issue 1 ending in Kirk's birth and issue 2 not having him in the academy yet. I understand it's a nice change to not have the hell edited out of an adaptation, but it would be nice to somehow have it paced a bit faster. Unfortunately IDG isn't a huge company and the economy dictates that they have to fill the back end of their books with pages of advertising instead of content. Come to think of it, at this pace the TPB will probably come out in more than one volume.

That's the price of being old! I come from the "100 Pages For 60 Cents" days of comics. Now I understand why older people bitch about movie ticket prices, etc. They used to pay a nickel to get in; I used to pay 30 cents for my comics.

--------

"Outer Space: The Last Frontier.

These are the trips of the Star Trek Enterprise. Its five year plan calls for us to explore strange new worlds, to seek out new life and new civilizations, to boldly fly where no man has gone in space. Live long, and be happy."




Patrick Stewart--SNL, Stardate 9402.05


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Waiting For The TPB by PatBorg @ 19:40:58 on Mar 20
    One By One by Jean-Luc @ 13:15:33 on Mar 21
RE: Waiting For The TPB by GustavoLeao @ 04:23:48 on Mar 18
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
This website is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc. or the "Star Trek" franchise.
The STAR TREK trademarks and logos are owned by CBS Studios Inc.
© 1996-2011 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.