menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman Discuss New Star Trek Movie Plot, Say Future of New Timeline is Totally Different

Features

By GustavoLeao / 18:25, 12 May 2009 / Star Trek: Nemesis

MTV posted a new interview with Star Trek writers Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman in which they answer 5 questions regarding the new movie plot. Here are excerpts.

MTV: Out of the entire universe, how do Elder Spock and Kirk happen to get stranded on the same planet? Are we expected to believe it's just a coincidence?


Orci
: Why was Spock put on that planet by Nero? Because of its proximity to Vulcan. And where was the Enterprise leaving when they decided to kick Kirk off the ship? Then it's not a coincidence, is it? Their proximity to that moon is very much by the plot.


Kurtzman
: One of the things we're playing to is the theme of destiny ... the idea that it wasn't actually random chance. It seems like random chance if you run into Spock in that cave, but it wasn't. And in some way, the time stream is trying to mend itself.


MTV
: And how about Scotty? Is it a coincidence that he happens to be on that moon as well?


Kurtzman
: It goes back to the idea that the time stream is trying to mend itself. These characters are essentially destined to find each other in one way or another - and that fate is literally bringing them together.


Orci
: If you read about quantum mechanics, you would have a further understanding of how there's a mathematical basis for destiny.


MTV
: Doesn't Elder Spock know how Captain Kirk dies in the "Generations" movie? Shouldn't he warn young Kirk to stay away from Dr. Tolian Soran?


Kurtzman: No, because remember - it's an alternate timeline now. So this future is totally different. There's no need to mention it; there's no boulder [fall] to warn him about.

More from Orci and Kurtzman on the new movie at MTV



More Top StoriesComments
Nov 06Rumor Mill : Bryan Singer Battlestar Galactica Movie is Underway ?7
Nov 06Star Trek Online MMORPG Game Gameplay Trailer Released Online 0
Nov 06First Images from the Upcoming Star Trek The Art of the Film Book4
Nov 05Brent Spiner Criticizes Insurrection and Defends Nemesis, Stuart Baird and Rick Berman20
Nov 05J.J. Abrams in Talks to Produce Micronauts Movie6
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

16 comments Post New | Help
View:

PRECISELY. Orci is being an idiot... | Report this post to moderator
By: Stilgar (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 23:48:40 on May 12, 2009 | Edit History (1)

... or an arts student. He seems to have NO IDEA about Quantum Mechanics... I wish they would STOP repeating this CRAP because it makes ST look ignorant and anti-science:

1. If anything, Quantum Mechanics or in this case more precisely chaos theory says the opposite to predestination. For example: Wikipedia Butterfly Effect

2. It is true that some HYPOTHESES (not even theories, just ideas) involving Quantum Mechanics say that all *possible* timelines exist with various probabilities. However, again, this DOES NOT support predestination or a timeline trying to right itself, but quite the OPPOSITE it says there are many possibilities CO-EXISTING. For example: Many Worlds Interpretation

--------

All message content � 2003 by Stilgar sietch_tabr[-at-]bigfoot.com, permission to reprint specifically denied to Michael Wong mike@stardestroyer.net ....



I have written about the new Abrams movie for just a short time. I have noticed I am being asked the same questions over and over again. Accordingly I have summarised the same questions I had to reply several times, in the interests of moving the discussion on from repetitions. Click on the "web site" link next to my name/handle. If I have not covered your particular point or argument, or if you think I am wrong, please feel free to question me about it.



BELOW Abrams-Trek: "It sounded like a good idea in the begining"


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: PRECISELY. Orci is being an idiot... by c.p. @ 08:01:37 on May 13
    The world will not be flat EVER again... by Stilgar @ 08:32:04 on May 13
       RE: The world will not be flat EVER again... by c.p. @ 08:52:42 on May 13
          True :) by Stilgar @ 09:07:31 on May 13

Okay, this IS the first major letdown for me | Report this post to moderator
By: DixonHill (Odo's file, contact) @ 21:16:44 on May 12, 2009 | Edit History (2)

Why was Spock put on that planet by Nero? Because of its proximity to Vulcan. And where was the Enterprise leaving when they decided to kick Kirk off the ship? Then it's not a coincidence, is it? Their proximity to that moon is very much by the plot.

Delta Vega is no way a Vulcan moon or something from which you can see Vulcan imploding. I was hoping Spock observing the destruction was just a holographic projection of sorts. Now, alternate timeline considered, Delta Vega doesn't shift from a far-out world at the edge of the galaxy near the Galactic Barrier to a moon of one of the core worlds of the Federation, just because Nero killed Kirk's father and destroyed the Kelvin!

Why call it Delta Vega...they could have just called it the Vulcan ice moon Glaciera for what it's worth...


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Okay, this IS the first major letdown for me by GustavoLeao @ 22:40:09 on May 12
    RE: Okay, this IS the first major letdown for me by JamesT @ 04:25:07 on May 13

Quantum Star Trek | Report this post to moderator
By: sb2004 (Odo's file, contact) @ 18:57:32 on May 12, 2009

Anyone who thinks Star Trek isn't true science fiction should read that comment about the new movie taking elements from quantum mechanics again.

Al


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Quantum Star Trek by Gprime85 @ 20:43:50 on May 12
RE: Quantum Star Trek by captainkoloth @ 19:23:42 on May 12
RE: Quantum Star Trek by Cylykon @ 19:16:22 on May 12
    RE: Quantum Star Trek by Latex Zebra @ 05:20:32 on May 13
    RE: Quantum Star Trek by Latex Zebra @ 05:20:23 on May 13
RE: Quantum Star Trek by richdun @ 19:16:19 on May 12
    Read the "quantum mechanics" link... by Stilgar @ 08:43:17 on May 13
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
© 1996-2009 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.