menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
STAR TREK BBS
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Comics Review : Star Trek Countdown Issue 2 - Movie Prequel Tie-In Comic Book

Features

By GustavoLeao / 03:32, 26 February 2009 / Star Trek: Nemesis

Star Trek: Countdown #2

Review by Patrick Hayes aka PatBorg

The covers:
David Messina does a beautiful Data for the "Cover Art" cover, while there is a fantastic "Retail Incentive Photo Cover" of the new Uhura--though she, in TOS or Relaunch movie mode, is nowhere to be found in this issue.  Overall grade: Cover Art A+ and RIPC A (simply because it has nothing to do with this comic's story).

The story: Story by Roberto Orci & Alex Kurtzman, with Writers Mike Johnson & Tim Jones.  You thought the first issue was good, then hold onto something because this issue only increased my interest a thousand fold. Captain Data and his crew of the U.S.S. Enterprise E rescue Spock, Nero and his crew from Reman sudden death.  And we're now 5 pages into the comic and you really don't want me spoiling anything.  Let's just say Romulans show their true colors.  There is a great "bust shot" on page 7 that made me rise out of my seat, especially in the context of what is going on to see that person's face.  Page 10 has a one balloon explanation that will make every Trek fan sigh in relief and smile in pleasure, yet leave them with unfulfilled promises from Trek films.  It almost washed out the bad taste in my mouth left by Nemesis.  Pages 11 and 12 wonderfully show the motivati on of a world.  The "new to this series" alien race that appears on pages 14 and 15 brought back too many unpleasant memories of Enterprise, which happily (thankfully!) left with the introduction of a character on page 16.  This character was a very welcome addition!  Pages 19 through 24 give the upcoming film's antagonist motivation.  How this will be explained in the film for those that haven't read this book leaves me wondering.  The protagonists of the book are on the predictable "buck the higher ups" as they try to save the world.  It's what I expect of them, so since this wasn't a surprise I'm hopeful that there will be a twist soon.  Romulans and Nero dominate this issue, so much so that I was upset when the focus was taken away from them.  I have a million questions about what favorite characters have been up to since Nemesis, but that's not the point of this series, which is to se t up the movie.  This issue left me wanting more, more, more!&n bsp; And that last page!  Again a winner!  I knew that this was going to happen at some point, but in issue two?  C'mon!  What's left?  I'm in eager anticipation to find out.  Overall grade: A+

The art: David Messina has created a cinematic comic.  The close-ups of characters speak volumes, especially on Nero.  Messina brings a lot of black to this work, not as much as in the previous Mirror Mirror series from last year, but enough to let readers know that there are dark secrets and decisions being made.  Every shot of Spock broke my heart: he's so old and his vision of reunification is so close, yet so far away.  I know he doesn't die in this series, as he's in the film, but if he were to keel over in sorrow and expire it wouldn't shock me.  I love the background on pages 11 and 12: as it's similar to a setting first (and only) shown in Generations.  A nice setting from the movie is previewed on page 18.  And it's very accurate--since I've been where it was filmed in Whittier, California!  Who knew Vulcan was in Whittier?  My favorite page was 24: it has perfect writing and perfect arti stic layout.  It's like a scene from a movie as the "camera" slowly closes in on the character.  That final eye bulge would rip any father/husband's heart out!  And again, a real winner with the two panel last page!  Overall grade: A+

The colors: Color Art by Giovanna Niro and Color Consultant by Ilaria Traversi.  Space continues to look lovely and threatening all at once.  Romulan space seems insidious in blacks and blues, while Vulcan comes off in golden yellows.  The coloring fits the tone of the book.  Overall grade: A+

The letters: Neil Uyetake does a competent job with dialogue and 3 sound effects that are gone after page 4.  Hooray for a transporter whine!  Thank you, Neil!  Overall grade: A

Overall grade: I have no doubt that any Trekfan would enjoy this comic.  The Romulans are the definite focus of the series, and I haven't enjoyed them so much since TNG.  Overall grade: A



More Top StoriesComments
Feb 09Zachary Quinto Says Star Trek XII is Bigger and Bolder, Says the Actors were Brought to the Process of Working the Script
3
Feb 09Chris Pine on the Casting of Rising Star Benedict Cumberbatch as the Chief Villain in Star Trek XII 0
Feb 09Evangelion Director Anno to Design Yamato 2199 Anime Opening0
Feb 08In Search of, 70s TV Series Hosted by Leonard Nimoy, Coming to DVD5
Feb 08Read a 7-Page Preview of Star Trek Legion of Super Heroes 5
2
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

14 comments Post New | Help
View:

Deja vu | Report this post to moderator
By: sb2004 (Odo's file, contact) @ 16:52:31 on Feb 27, 2009

I agree #2 was great, and the comic has been terrific so far. But am I the only one concerned that the backstory being established for the new movie is basically a rehash of the backstory for Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country? (Natural disaster threatening existence of mortal enemy of the Federation; Federation bigwigs debate whether to bother helping.)

Al


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

Great story, Art is very trace-y. | Report this post to moderator
By: Bucky (Odo's file, contact) @ 00:28:01 on Feb 27, 2009

Kind of like Greg Land where the artist is clearly tracing live action pics and inserting them into the story. (Check out the last page where he's swiping from one of Nero's first ST pics available online.) It can look decent, but it's fairly static. However, I'm so jazzed to read a final TNG sendoff / prequel/sequel to the next Trek movie, that I'll take stick figures as long as I get the story. But calling it A+? I'd say go read a few more comics before calling it that.

--------

An elephant never forgets . . .TO KILL!


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: A question for you... by PatBorg @ 00:21:54 on Feb 28

its comin..its comin | Report this post to moderator
By: Welshie (Odo's file, contact) @ 18:35:29 on Feb 26, 2009

Great issue, can't wait for three and four!


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

The Artwork | Report this post to moderator
By: The One (Odo's file, contact) @ 18:17:27 on Feb 26, 2009

Is Fantastic. I've never seen the ST Universe look so good on the comic page, and it is captured beautifully and the things we know (Mostly the Enterprise Interior)are conveyed more faithfully than I can recall... awesome.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

Captain Data | Report this post to moderator
By: GustavoLeao (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 10:53:45 on Feb 26, 2009

Thank God they finally reveal how Data can be the captain of the Enterprise-E years after Nemesis in this issue. God job, Orci and Kurtzman.

Gustavo

--------

TrekWeb.com Supervising Editor



gl2000@uol.com.br


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Captain Data by Capricorn Two @ 17:57:26 on Feb 26
    RE: Captain Data by The One @ 18:20:47 on Feb 26

#2 was great | Report this post to moderator
By: Welshie (Odo's file, contact) @ 09:34:40 on Feb 26, 2009

Wow #2 was a great read, again leaving me with lots of anticipation for numbers three and four. I thought it continued well, was not out of context, and no irregularities. This so far is a great prequel to the movie, and number 4 will surely seal the deal. GO READ IT NOW!


"too many unpleasant memories of Enterprise" What the hell is that supposed to mean lol?

UH OH, ENTERPRISE RANT!

Please someone say Enterprise sucks once more, please once more, just once more, please. Why does everyone hate on Enterprise, I thought it was one of the most original Trek shows. People say it is not Star Trek it does not deal with morality...did those people even watch the show? I will forgo the list of morality that Enterprise brought because it would be too long to list. Enterprise spews with morality, granted you cant expect the characters to act like their counterparts from 200 years in the future, but the crew of the enterprise still fights the good fight and does what is right. Did you expect humans to be utopian in 2154? I thought Enterprise was great, pre federation, Starfleet was still young, space was virtually unexplored by humans, just starting to use the transporter, we are shown how many things come into play like "Reed" alert, recoil of the phasers, etc, etc, etc. I even thought the Starfleet logo and uniforms were great considering the era it takes place. I thought Braga and Berman outdid themselves with Enterprise, (they may have messed up Generations and Nemesis) but they did a fantastic job on Enterprise, they gave me the "beginnings" of many things I have been craving for so many years.

NOTHING in Enterprise makes me want to go back and change things the way I want to with Generations or Nemesis. Kirk should not have died and Data should not have died. I am sure they have more then one of those transport devices lying around and he could have set the phaser to overload. Please god please let someone give me a legitimate reason why Star Trek Enterprise was terrible, something more concrete then what the typical fan says, "it was bad." Enterprise was a nice break from all the etiquette of Picard. DS9 and Voyager were simply a continuation of the Next Generation where Enterprise was a welcome freshness like the morning dew.

Enterprise was a GREAT show and it sits proudly up there with my other Star Trek DVD's in my collection completing the saga to date.

A few years back I sent Branon and Rick each a letter telling them how much I appreciated their work and how cynical and hypocritical some star trek fans can be, and those fans contradict the reason they watch Star Trek, the very thing they belive in by hating on Enterprise, understanding and acceptance of all. In the end I am happy…hate all you want…Star Trek Enterprise is part of history, its part of the Star Trek universe and mythos and there is NOTHING you can do to change that! ITS CANON…DEAL WITH IT!


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
Just want to clarify... by PatBorg @ 00:19:53 on Feb 28
RE: #2 was great by Kirk Archer @ 20:11:11 on Feb 26
RE: #2 was great by cdydatzigs @ 13:49:46 on Feb 26
RE: #2 was great by Disposable Red Shirt @ 11:39:33 on Feb 26
RE: #2 was great by Captain's Blog @ 10:05:41 on Feb 26
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
This website is not endorsed, sponsored or affiliated with CBS Studios Inc. or the "Star Trek" franchise.
The STAR TREK trademarks and logos are owned by CBS Studios Inc.
© 1996-2011 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.